I suppose Fat Tuesday is an appropriate day to be posting this recipe. So I will do it without feeling guilty for the inch I may be adding to your waistline.
This recipe has been in our family's repertoire for quite awhile. I've always loved how simple it is, as well as the moan and groan response (the good kind) you get when you serve it up for guests.
And while this might seem like something that should be served up in the dead heat of summer, with my current no-oven handicap, it is the perfect thing. And personally, I can do peanut butter and chocolate year round. Can't you?
So the original recipe is for an easy Peanut Butter Pie, but this time I wanted to somehow add a chocolate element to the recipe. And not just any chocolate…I wanted a fudgy, rich layer of chocolate in the pie.
And man oh man, if I didn't hit the nail on the head with my first try….you're welcome. 🙂
Peanut Butter Pie (with a Twist)
4 oz. cream cheese
1 cup powdered sugar
1/4 cup milk
1/3 cup creamy peanut butter
Beat together these ingredients until smooth and combined. Fold in 8 ounces of whipped topping (ie. cool whip). Set aside.
Meanwhile, over medium heat melt about 8 ounces of milk chocolate chips and about half of a 14-ounce can of sweetened condensed milk. Stir constantly until smooth and chocolate has melted.
Evenly spread the chocolate into the bottom of a 10-inch pie pan with a Graham Cracker crust. (note: I had to use store-bought crust b/c of not having the oven and it does keep this recipe simple. But homemade is so very yummy.)
On top of the chocolate fudge layer spread the whipped peanut butter topping.
Cover and freeze overnight or at least several hours.
Serve in petite slices, trust me.
FYI: The photograph is of the very last piece. When I brought the pie to dinner at my dad's the other night, my only request was to save me one last piece–for photographic purposes, of course. Next time I should remember to take a picture of the first piece. She was much more attractive. 🙂
13 comments on “pie with a twist”
Ooo…I have a cooking light version, but this looks much better!
that looks sooo yummy. sigh….. 😉
Yes I can eat peanut butter & chocolate anytime. Yum yum.
You don’t have to bake a graham cracker crust. melt butter and mix with broken up graham cracker and a touch of sugar….I have several pottery pie pans and it takes a package and half of cracker to a half a stick of butter to a couple of tablespoons of sugar….mash it into the pie pan and you are ready to go!!:) if you are using for a cheese cake add chopped pecans YUM!!!
mmmmm, that looks and sounds mighty yummy.
Do I have to do in my oven to make this smashing pie? Because I would, I surely would… Thank YOU!
yum! I have heard of a recipe like this where you use nutter butter cookies crumbled and made into a crust…. any way you make it — DELICIOUS!
I made this today and it was quite yummy, but the chocolate layer was so hard I almost had to use a jack hammer to get through it. Did you have this problem? Maybe I used too much chocolate. (to much chocolate??? no such thing!)
Thanks for the recipe and the advice on the petite pieces!
Made this for the family and my dad (big pb pie fan) Thurs. night…it was a big hit. Everyone was glad they took your advice about a small piece. A nice cup of decaf helps temper the richness though! Thanks for the recipe!
I remember this pie from college days! Very dangerous, indeed. So glad to finally have the recipe!
Wow its look so Yummy!your pictures making my mouth watery ..its looks very tasty and sweet too,Let me allow to try all your food stuffs ,My tongue is melting to have your recipe.
Very yummy and superb dish. But what is the meaning of only one piece, I hope you can make and share more pieces on next time.
I will save this recipe and make it next weekend for our Fourth of July picnic party. I am making the fried chicken, too.